Denetdale Works to Reclaim Navajo History

Jen­nifer Nez Denetdale

Jen­nifer Nez Denet­dale grew up in Tohatchi, N.M., a Navajo com­mu­nity 25 miles north of Gallup. She and her three sis­ters and one brother never missed school, she said, because her father insisted they become edu­cated. “We always had books in our home. When ped­dlers would come by sell­ing speed read­ers, vocab­u­lary builders or ency­clo­pe­dias, he bought them,” she said.

That drive to edu­ca­tion wasn’t lost on Denet­dale. She came to UNM where she stud­ied Eng­lish for her bachelor’s degree.

Lucy Tapa­honso, UNM Depart­ment of Eng­lish, was an early men­tor for Denet­dale. “She was both the first native and Navajo pro­fes­sor I had. The late Louis Owens was won­der­ful – let­ting me know the pos­si­bil­i­ties in the acad­emy,” Denet­dale said.

She went to North­ern Ari­zona Uni­ver­sity for her master’s in Eng­lish and doc­tor­ate in his­tory. She taught his­tory at UNM and NAU, then came back to UNM and is now an asso­ciate pro­fes­sor in Amer­i­can studies.

I love the inter­dis­ci­pli­nary nature that engages in crit­i­cal stud­ies of the United States as a nation in and beyond its bor­ders,” she said, not­ing that she focuses specif­i­cally on issues of race, class and gender.

A Navajo con­text
Her early men­tors stressed the value of sto­ry­telling in both lit­er­a­ture and his­tory. “Using the his­tor­i­cal con­text pro­vided through oral tra­di­tion, native schol­ars chal­lenge the academy’s his­tory of the Navajo based on doc­u­ments cre­ated by non-Indians. Those come with a par­tic­u­lar bias. We chal­lenge the bound­aries they erect,” she said.

Denet­dale con­ducts research from the ground up, look­ing to the Navajo and native com­mu­ni­ties to cre­ate research ques­tions. “Thus, native research is trans­form­ing native stud­ies because it is about cre­at­ing mod­els of research that directly address the issues and prob­lems we face as native nations,” she said.

Denet­dale writes from the per­spec­tive of a Navajo woman “priv­i­leged with the oral tra­di­tions of the past,” she said. She added that she came to appre­ci­ate cer­e­monies and prayers and the knowl­edge and power they rep­re­sent in the Navajo way.

From fam­ily his­tory to national his­tory
Denet­dale authored, “Reclaim­ing Diné His­tory: the lega­cies of Navajo Chief Manuelito and Juanita,” after talk­ing about the Diné leader and his wife with her own grand­par­ents. “As a matri­lin­eal cul­ture, we think about the past through moth­ers and grand­moth­ers,” she said.

Denet­dale recalls that at a fam­ily reunion she was asked to speak about the mean­ing of K’e – the rela­tion­ships that shape how Nava­jos respond to each other and the rest of the world. In the 1990s, she inter­viewed her grand­fa­ther Mike Alli­son, who had told her sto­ries of their great-great-great-grandmother, Juanita.

My grand­fa­ther wanted the younger gen­er­a­tion to know how we’re related and shared with us the sto­ries of Manuelito and Juanita,” she said. Among the sto­ries was how he was a leader of those who resisted the Mex­i­can and U.S. inva­sion on Navajo land.

Based upon the sto­ries I heard from my grand­par­ents like Mike Alli­son, who died sev­eral years ago, and from Amer­i­can sources, I shared my insights and told my clan rel­a­tives that we all have warrior’s blood in our veins. Our grand­fa­ther Manuelito told us that land was impor­tant to our peo­ple and to pro­tect it for future gen­er­a­tions. He said that edu­ca­tion isn’t just for our pur­poses, but to be put to use to pro­tect land for the future,” she said.

Cross­ing cul­tures
Manuelito under­stood that Nava­jos needed to under­stand the ways of the non-natives and so he sent two of his sons to Carlisle Indian School in Penn­syl­va­nia in 1880s.

His sons went with the first group of Nava­jos as a mes­sage to his peo­ple that edu­ca­tion was impor­tant to Navajo peo­ple – not to become white peo­ple but to ensure the sov­er­eignty of the Navajo Nation,” she said.
Denet­dale found pic­tures of Manuelito’s two sons when she was invited to accom­pany Navajo stu­dents who took a field trip to the site of the Carlisle Indian School in Carlisle, Penn. There, she was able to spend a few days in the Cum­ber­land His­tor­i­cal Society’s archives and learn about Navajo stu­dents at the Carlisle school.

It was very emo­tional to see, and think of their jour­ney across the west. Within a year, one son died there. The other was sick and came home at the request of his father. He died at home. At that point, Manuelito asked all the Navajo chil­dren to come home,” she said. By the early 1900s, oth­ers went.

Denetdale’s par­ents are prod­ucts of Stew­art Indian School, a board­ing school in Car­son City, Nev. Her par­ents speak Navajo, she said, but “we weren’t taught because of their expe­ri­ences that were both trau­matic and vio­lent. They thought it would be bet­ter if we spoke Eng­lish,” she said.

Through her research and con­duct­ing inter­views with her grand­par­ents, Denet­dale said she improved her abil­ity to speak Navajo. Two of her three grand­chil­dren are learn­ing the lan­guage, as well.

Media Con­tact: Car­olyn Gon­za­les (505) 277‑5920; e-mail: cgonzal@unm.edu

Posted in Academics & Faculty, University News |